Joined: 01 Aug 2006
Location: Richland, Washington State, USA
|Posted: Sun May 04, 2008 9:21 am Post subject:
|I have no hands-on experience with Photomatix.
However, from quite a bit of experience (and theory) with other alignment tools, I would not be very hopeful.
There is an implicit assumption in HDR work that the images are identical except for exposure. That means all images are focused the same, which also means the alignment process is particularly simple because every feature you choose to look at is almost identical (except for brightness) in different frames.
But in focus stacking, it is specifically the point that most details do not look identical in different frames. A few details in the zone of focus overlap do look identical, but there are gobs of other details that are fuzzy in one, sharp in the other. This makes life quite a bit more challenging for focus alignment.
This is not to say that PhotoMatix alignment won't do a good job in many cases, perhaps even most. But for the tougher cases, like deep stacks through microscope objectives, I'd expect to get better results from other tools that have been wrung out with those kinds of images.